Kohana and MODx?I wanted to comment on an interesting post on the Kohana site that I came across this morning by yehosef. I am not extolling the virtues of Kohana by any means, in all honesty I was completely unaware of it’s existence until a few hours ago.

I frequently state that “I am not a programmer”, but rather a developer who specializes in building sites in MODx. MODx allows me to create lots of really cool site features in varying ways. One limitation (primarily my own) is that when I come across custom, development requests that seem completely outside the scope of what I can currently create with MODX I tend to struggle and often need to bring in a programmer. While there is nothing inherently wrong with that approach my own vanity demands that I have as many tools in my own toolbox as I possibly can.

Which brings me to the Kohana post I referenced above:

Instead of building a CMS from scratch, I have embeded Kohana inside MODx (Evolution 1.0.2). For those that have used it, MODx is a CMS with a very simple and powerful approach. I would recommend checking it out – modxcms.com (again, Evo, not Revo).

BUT, programming on the backside is not so ideal. While they call it a Content Management Framework, the reality is not quite as rosy (look at Ditto/Wayfinder). By embedding Kohana (currently 2.3.4) development takes on an entirely different flavor and is significantly easier.

Expand your own capabilities and make life a little easier. At least conceptually, I get that.

  • chucktrukk
    Great post Greg. I hope more MODx devs use this approach. You can learn so much from the guys at CI, Kohana, Symfony. I am really excited about seeing an app framework inside of the best CMS.

    I've been doing this with Doctrine and Zend the past few months, and it makes heavy custom work much simpler. To be able to have a real framework with MVC + routing is soooo handy for heavy customizations.
  • Thanks for the response, that was exactly the kind of feedback I was hoping for with this post.

    I have been keeping an eye on your calendar thread: http://modxcms.com/forums/index.php/topic,34824... Great work.
blog comments powered by Disqus